For CAL — compute arbitrage verdict
One page. Three things to read before the next compute arbitrage meeting.
Verdict in one sentence
Keep storage on Wasabi eu-central-1 and rent compute by use-case from
OVH (CPU) or Nebius (GPU). All-in providers cost more and lock the data —
S3NS is defended only on the hackathon angle.
Three axes
| Axis | Status | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Storage | Wasabi 5.7 TiB, €380/yr, free egress under quota | stay |
| Compute | rented per-UC, no migration | mixed |
| Pipelines | Databento ingested ; S&P streaming | continue |
Top-2 architectures per use case
UC = use case (5 use cases indexed on the Wasabi corpus). Costs are compute + egress, annual, excluding storage.
| Use case | First choice | Second choice |
|---|---|---|
| UC-01 — student lab Databento ITCH (50 CPU-h/yr) | M2 Wasabi+OVH (~€10) | M5 Wasabi+Colab (€0, preemptive) |
| UC-02 — student lab S&P \(\times\) RavenPack (100 CPU-h/yr) | M2 Wasabi+OVH (~€20) | M3 Wasabi+Scaleway (~€32) |
| UC-03 — backtest 1y cross-asset (240 CPU-h/yr) | M2 Wasabi+OVH (~€50) | M1 Wasabi+Nebius (~€100) |
| UC-04 — GPU sentiment fine-tune (240 GPU-h/yr) | M1 Wasabi+Nebius H100 (~€700) | M2 Wasabi+OVH H100 (~€600 if quote \(\leq\) €2.80/h) |
| UC-05 — agentic hackathon (130 CPU-h/yr + tokens) | A4 S3NS all-in (partnership signal) | M5 Wasabi+Colab (€0) |
Detail per cell — friction, lock-in, sovereignty — scenario matrix §4.
Three atomic open questions
Each question is one decision. Reply 1 / 2 / 3 — no compound answers.
-
Is SecNumCloud sovereignty a pedagogical deliverable of the Master?
- yes — A4 (S3NS all-in) re-enters UC-01 to UC-04 under a competitive quote.
- no — A4 stays parked on UC-05 only.
- defer — we keep the mixed default and re-open after a written brief.
-
Is the S3NS hackathon (UC-05) activated as a programme deliverable?
- yes — we open an ephemeral S3NS bucket for UC-05 only ; the rest of the corpus stays on Wasabi.
- no — UC-05 runs on Colab + Wasabi (M5).
- defer — we hold the S3NS slot until June.
-
Which compute provider for UC-01 to UC-04 by default?
- OVH (M2) — cheapest, FR-sovereign.
- Nebius (M1) — best for GPU, EU-sovereign (FI).
- Scaleway (M3) — FR alternative if academic credit is negotiated.
Hidden cost reminder
Migrating 5.7 TiB from Wasabi to any all-in provider is 0 € in egress fees but 9–18 days of continuous transfer on commercial bandwidth (measured 25–47 Mbps), plus checksum-reconciliation work on buckets without vendor MD5, plus the loss of Wasabi's zero-egress regime on future flows. Not a non-event.
Sources
- Full matrix:
docs/compute/scenario-matrix.md - Egress doctrine:
docs/compute/cost-model.md - Wasabi state (volumes):
docs/wasabi/state.md - Decision tree (visual):
docs/diagrams/m2-compute-arbitrage.md